Department of Management seminar with Professor Gülen Abi, Copenhagen Business School Algorithm Pollution: Why Consumers Resist AI Advisors in Circular Economy Services
AI advisors are increasingly deployed in circular economy services, yet consumers may not welcome algorithmic guidance in environmentally charged contexts. Across preregistered experiments combining qualitative data, behavioural measures, and incentive compatible donation decisions, we show that consumers prefer human over AI advisors for recycling and circular fashion decisions, even when both provide equivalent guidance. This preference is not explained by perceived competence, privacy concerns, warmth, or social presence. Instead, consumers view AI as environmentally misaligned with circular economy goals, a belief we term perceived algorithm pollution. This perception lowers service satisfaction, brand evaluations, advisor trust, recommendation acceptance, and participation in circular programs. We test three organizational interventions: regenerative by design AI and independent environmental review both reduce perceived algorithm pollution and improve consumer responses, whereas fee based environmental compensation backfires. The findings contribute to research on AI aversion, sustainable consumption, and responsible AI governance.